Open five real estate portals this week and you will see five different medians for Forest Hills. PropertyShark puts the June 2026 figure at $417,000. Steadily reports around $450,000. One local Corcoran brokerage puts it at $615,000. Zillow lands at $607,250. Movoto shows a $389,000 list median.
They are not wrong. They are measuring different neighborhoods. Forest Hills behaves as three distinct markets that share a zip code, and the number you see depends entirely on which one dominated last quarter's sales mix. If you are comparing Queens neighborhoods on a portal, this is the piece of local knowledge that changes what your budget actually buys.
The clearest way to see Forest Hills is to stop looking at the neighborhood median and start looking at the segment medians. As of Q2 2026, the three ladders sit at very different rungs:
| Segment | Median Sale Price | Median Days on Market | Approx. Monthly Sales |
|---|---|---|---|
| Co-ops | $347K–$400K | ~222 days | ~76 (with condos) |
| Condos | $815K–$1.1M | ~222 days | included above |
| Houses (attached & detached) | ~$2.2M | ~79 days | ~12 |
The co-op figure comes from PropertyShark's Q2 2026 read and StreetEasy data through March 2026. The condo range spans a local brokerage's steady-state read and PropertyShark's June 2026 number, which jumped 123.7% year over year on the strength of a handful of luxury closings at The Austin Condominium and similar buildings. The house median reflects a market where roughly a dozen properties trade per month and inventory is thin enough that renovated homes tend to draw aggressive bidding.
Three ladders. Three different stories. A portal that weights the mix toward co-op transactions shows a soft market. A portal that weights toward condos or houses shows appreciation. Both are describing Forest Hills.
The gap between a Forest Hills co-op and a comparable condo runs about 30%, according to figures tracked by a local Terrace Sotheby's agent. On the surface that looks like free money for a patient buyer. It is not. It is compensation for a friction the portals never show you.
Every co-op purchase requires board approval, and that process regularly adds several weeks to a closing that already runs longer than a typical NYC condo deal. Boards examine post-closing liquidity, debt-to-income ratios, and reference letters. They also, as any Forest Hills agent will tell you, resist approving lowball offers because a low comp weakens every other shareholder's balance sheet. That is why co-op days on market in Forest Hills sit near 222 days while houses clear in 79. It is not that co-ops are unwanted. It is that each transaction carries paperwork, timing, and financial-disclosure friction the house market does not.
For a downsizing seller moving from a Brownstone Brooklyn townhouse into a Forest Hills co-op, this friction cuts two ways. The board scrutiny that slows your purchase is the same scrutiny that will support your resale price years later. Maintenance fees typically bundle property taxes, heat, and water into one monthly line, which changes the co-op-versus-condo monthly math in ways a headline price cannot capture. A $400,000 co-op with $1,500 in monthly maintenance and a $500,000 condo with $400 in common charges plus separate taxes can carry closer than the sticker gap suggests.
There is also a supply distortion worth naming. The Forest Hills co-op market almost always has 150 or more studio and one-bedroom listings active at any moment, most concentrated in the postwar high-rises along Queens Boulevard and Yellowstone Boulevard. A buyer scanning that inventory sees abundance and assumes leverage. The board approval process quietly removes that leverage at the offer stage.
Inside Forest Hills sits Forest Hills Gardens, the landmarked private community of Tudor Revival houses, stucco center-halls, and pre-war garden co-ops laid out around Station Square. Sales here move on a different clock than the rest of the neighborhood.
Recent Gardens co-op closings in 2025 and early 2026 include units at 1 Station Square, 150 Burns Street, 20 Continental Avenue, 4 Dartmouth Street, 6 Burns Street, 10 Holder Place, and 1 Ascan Avenue. These buildings offer very little in the way of amenities compared to newer Queens Boulevard high-rises. What they offer is location within the private community, mature streetscape, and access to Station Square and the LIRR platform that puts Penn Station about 17 minutes away. Buyers pay for that, and the values have held or increased even in quarters when the broader co-op median softened.
If you filter a portal search by Forest Hills and see a $347K co-op median, you are looking at a number that mostly reflects the postwar high-rises, not the Gardens. Comparable Gardens units often clear well above that. The reverse is true for the Tudor houses: the $2.2M house median is heavily influenced by Gardens closings and by Van Court and Cord Meyer sales. Move a few blocks outside the Gardens boundary and the same square footage in an attached rowhouse trades on a very different curve.
Austin Street sits at the seam between these markets. Condos along that corridor and the newer developments near 71st Avenue command the walk-to-everything premium, which is why the condo median has stretched as far as it has. Buildings like The Hamilton, The Cromwell, Lane Tower, The Girard in Forest Hills South, River Gardens, and The Greenbriar each carry their own board culture, layout stock, and price band. Treating them as a single "Forest Hills co-op" line item is where portal medians go wrong.
Before you draw any conclusion from a Forest Hills median, ask three questions:
Interest rates have held near 6% through 2026, according to a local market outlook from a Terrace Sotheby's agent, and inventory in the house segment remains tight because many potential sellers still hold sub-4% mortgages and have limited financial incentive to list. That supply lock is why renovated houses in Forest Hills Gardens and Van Court continue to clear quickly and often above ask, even as the co-op segment carries longer marketing periods.
For buyers moving from Brooklyn or Manhattan, the practical translation is this. A $500,000 budget lands you a solid postwar one-bedroom co-op with room for a board application. An $800,000 budget opens the condo tier with far less approval friction and easier future rentability. A $2 million budget starts the conversation about a Gardens house, but only if you can compete against buyers willing to move within a week of listing.
Are Forest Hills co-op maintenance fees higher than Brooklyn co-ops? Comparable pre-war and postwar Forest Hills co-ops often carry maintenance that includes property taxes, heat, and water in a single line. Brooklyn co-ops vary more widely. Compare the all-in monthly carrying cost, not the maintenance figure alone.
Why do some Forest Hills listings sit for 200-plus days? Long DOM in the co-op segment usually reflects board pricing discipline and the reality that studio and one-bedroom inventory is deep. It is not a signal that the individual apartment has a problem.
Does the FARE Act affect a buyer? The FARE Act, in effect since August 2024, shifted the broker fee to landlords who engage a broker on rentals. It changes rental comps buyers sometimes use to estimate future rentability of a condo, so lean on recent net rents rather than gross listing rents when you model the numbers.
Forest Hills rewards buyers who understand which of its three markets they are actually shopping in, and sellers who price against the correct comparable set rather than the neighborhood headline. If you are weighing a move from Brooklyn, helping a parent downsize into a Queens co-op, or comparing a Gardens house against a Park Slope brownstone, Binnie Sen can walk you through the segment-level numbers and the board dynamics behind them. Let's talk about your next move.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Navigate your next chapter with confidence. Whether you're downsizing, rightsizing, or helping a loved one transition, Binnie provides patient guidance, trusted expertise, and personalized support every step of the way.